The Lesbian Deported For Ugandan Discussions With A Man


This story is just quite lovely, so many levels to it. There is, obviously enough, the Private Eye fnarr fnarr over Ugandan discussions:

A lesbian asylum seeker kicked out of the UK because she was caught in bed with a man

Said lesbian originating from Uganda of course.

And yes, that particular joke does go one stage further:

In his judgment, Mr Justice Lewis recorded that the woman’s response to questioning over her relationship with the man was that they had not had sex but that she was considering getting pregnant. The judge noted that PN told immigration officials that her relationship with the man was “just a recent thing because I wanted a child”.

Indeed, discussing whether to create a little Ugandan.

On a slightly higher level there’s that very British thing of trying to insist upon the rules. A Ugandan cannot just come to England because they feel like it would be a better place to make a life. Perhaps they should be able to, perhaps not, but they can’t. There must be some reason why they can claim asylum. As it happens, opinions about the LGBT in Uganda are such that this is a reason why – often enough – asylum is granted in the UK.

At which point we start saying that those rulz is rulz. We’re just one of those sorts of places where we do think they’re important. So, if she’s in bed with a man she’s not a lesbian and therefore she can’t claim asylum on the grounds of being a supporter of Sappho.

Fair enough really.

And then we get really, really, British. Hang on a minute, are we really going to give in to the men with clipboards?

The woman, 26, who first came to the UK nearly ten years ago, is also entitled to claim financial damages from the government because she was unlawfully detained and deported, the High Court has ruled. In a judgment published last week Mr Justice Lewis ruled that the woman had been denied the chance to present evidence to show that she was in a lesbian relationship in Uganda. The Home Office had relied on information from immigration investigators that the woman, known only as PN, had lied about her sexual orientation before deporting her.

Much of the Home Office case relied on evidence gained during a raid of PN’s London flat, during which investigators forced open her bedroom door to find the Ugandan woman in bed with a man.

Now, seriously, how many countries, how many legal systems, would bother with that? We done her wrong and we’re going to make it up to her? Go find her from thousands of miles away, get her back here, compensate here and then……well, and then she’s going to have to try to prove her sexuality all over again ‘coz rulz is rulz.

Sorry, I just think that’s a great British story. Illustrates rather a lot about us all.

Unlike many news organisations, we chose an approach that means all our reporting is free and available for everyone. We need your support to keep delivering quality journalism, to maintain our openness and to protect our precious independence. Every reader contribution, big or small, is so valuable.
For as little as £1 (£10 if you were at OxBridge) you can support us – and it only takes a minute. Thank you.

Click Here To Make A Contribution - Tim & The Team